For Sale in Sag Harbor: ‘The Premiere Retail Development Project on the East End’

A Sag Harbor property that had been the proposed site of the new Bay Street Theater and then put back up for sale when plans fell through in 2023 has been relaunched along with the addition of a neighboring commercial site.

Hal Zwick and Jeffery Sztorc of Hamptons Commercial Real Estate at Compass exclusively represent the contiguous properties, which went on the market together for the first time earlier this month.

“This is the premier retail development project on the East End at this time,” Zwick tells Behind The Hedges. “Not only is it a rare waterfront development — it is already connected to the sewer system therefore allowing a combination of restaurant, take-out food, and traditional retail outlets — all with the approval of the Sag Harbor municipality.”

The price is only available upon request, but the price is likely over $30 million.

Zwick says that they are not publishing the price to offset any gossip. “We release it after screening applicants,” he says.

View the Article on